You Don’t Have to Feel Grateful for Everything
“I’m exhausted. But I should be grateful.”
Have you ever caught yourself saying something like that? You start to admit how you feel, then add a correction so you don’t sound unappreciative.
It’s an easy habit to fall into, especially in November. Between Thanksgiving and the reminders to count our blessings, gratitude gets a lot of airtime. Admitting that you’re disappointed or worn out can feel a little awkward when everyone is sharing what they’re thankful for.
But having good things in your life doesn’t explain away everything that’s hard. Sometimes “I should be grateful” cuts off a conversation that might have been worth having.
You don’t have to call it a gift
There’s a difference between appreciating the person who helped you through something and feeling grateful that it happened.
Maybe a friend kept checking in during a painful season. You’re thankful for her. The experience itself? You’d still rather have skipped it.
Even when something changes your priorities or teaches you something useful, that doesn’t necessarily make it a gift. Looking back, you might recognize what you learned and wish you could have learned it another way.
There’s no need to settle on a positive interpretation while you’re still figuring out how you feel. Some experiences look different with time. Others remain things you would never have chosen.
What comes before the “but”?
“I love having everyone here, but I’m exhausted.”
That sounds reasonable enough. Then comes the second thought: I shouldn’t complain. I’m lucky to have family.
Of course you appreciate them. You might also have been grocery shopping, cooking, and answering questions about where things are all afternoon. Being thankful for the people at your table doesn’t wash the dishes.
The same thing happens with opportunities we wanted. A job can be exciting and take more out of you than you expected. A commitment can matter to you and still need adjusting.
If every complaint gets dismissed as ingratitude, it becomes harder to notice what needs attention. Sometimes the useful part of “I’m exhausted” is realizing you need help, or that you’ve agreed to more than you have time for.
When gratitude feels like homework
A gratitude practice can be enjoyable. It can also become one more thing to do correctly.
If you’re searching for an answer that sounds meaningful enough to write down, try being more specific. Was there a moment you enjoyed today? Did someone do something that made your afternoon easier?
Maybe someone brought you coffee without asking you to find the mugs first.
An ordinary moment is enough to notice. It doesn’t need to change your opinion of the whole day.
And on a day when the exercise feels irritating, that’s useful information too. You might prefer a walk or an early night.
A small experiment
The next time you hear yourself say, “I feel _____, but I should be grateful,” stop after the first part.
What were you about to dismiss?
You don’t need to spend the evening analyzing it. Just consider whether there’s something practical you’ve been overlooking. Would asking someone else to handle dinner help? Is there a conversation you’ve been avoiding?
You could also ask:
What’s helping me get through this?
That question may be easier to answer than “What am I grateful for?” It leaves room to acknowledge the difficulty while recognizing the support you have.
Resting with an unfinished day
One thing I value about Yoga Nidra is that it doesn’t require much conversation. You can lie down without explaining your mood or giving an account of your day.
You might still be annoyed about something. Your mind may keep returning to tomorrow’s plans. The practice gives you something to follow while you rest, even with those things unresolved.
As November approaches, I’m interested in a version of gratitude that doesn’t require so much editing. Appreciation tends to mean more when it reflects what we actually feel.
A practice to try
I created a 10-minute Yoga Nidra meditation for finding a little peace within when life feels unsettled. Find a comfortable place to lie down and follow along.
If you’d prefer a gratitude-focused practice, Gratitude As Medicine is also available. This earlier recording combines guided Yoga Nidra with crystal bowls.
Comments